Choosing a Slurry Pump - Features

Nnamdi Nwaokocha offers practical advice on pump selection

Contact us to discuss your requirements of High quality slurry pumps. Our experienced sales team can help you identify the options that best suit your needs.

PUMPS are the backbone of the process industry. In a process plant, it is necessary to move material from one point to another. In keeping with the laws of thermodynamics, fluids move from an area of high pressure to low, and depending on the plant layout often require the assistance of a pump to achieve this. With many different pump types available, selecting the right pump can be tricky, especially when slurries are involved.

This article will discuss some of the variables to consider when characterising a slurry and selecting a suitable pump for transporting those slurries in a plant. This is not definitive and is by no means a complete review of handling slurries by pumping but is meant to provide some useful information and a good starting point of what to consider.

In a spin: Slurry centrifugal pump with rubber lined casing and rubber impeller

Summary

Pumping of slurries can often lead to blockages or equipment failure. The job of the designer is to assess all the factors of each situation, including client and existing site preferences to design a system and select a pump which is robust enough to minimise blockages and makes maintenance for operators as easy as capital would permit whilst providing a safe system of work.

Slurry type

What is a slurry? Typically, the term slurry is used to refer to a mixture of a liquid and a solid or combination of solids. The liquid is often referred to as the carrier fluid and in most cases is water, although it can be anything from an acid solution (eg nitric acid) to a hydrocarbon (eg diesel).

Producing a slurry or maintaining solid suspension in static conditions is outside the scope of this article.

Slurries can broadly be broken down into two types: settling, and non-settling slurries. This characterisation is based on the nature of the solid(s). Non-settling slurries contain solids made up of fine particles, which largely remain in suspension when the applied mixing energy ceases. Settling slurries, as the name suggests, contain solids whose particles settle out when the applied mixing energy ceases. From a designer’s perspective, it is important to know the type of slurry. For example, non-settling slurries can be transported around under laminar flow conditions, whereas turbulent flow conditions are required for settling slurries, particularly in horizontal sections.

A useful rule of thumb provided in Sinnot and Towler’s Chemical Engineering Design states that solids with particles of less than 200 microns (0.2 mm) will usually be expected to produce non-settling slurries. Larger particle sizes will produce settling slurries.1

Before selecting the right pump, the first step is to determine the pressure drop requirements using the system characteristics. The parameters required are:

The following equations2 are useful in determining the slurry’s density:

For settling slurries, the velocity in the pipework is the key design criteria.

Perry’s Chemical Engineers’ Handbook

Figure 1: The relationship between the pressure drop and the slurry’s velocity compared to a pure liquid in horizontal pipework

Figure 1, an extract from Perry’s Chemical Engineers’ Handbook, depicts the relationship between the pressure drop and the slurry’s velocity compared to a pure liquid in horizontal pipework. The important point to note is that the horizontal pipe velocity should be above the point labelled Vm2 (minimum transport velocity). This is the point at which the solids are fully suspended. This is determined using the Durand equation3. 

where:

Once the minimum transport velocity is calculated, it is common to add a safety factor, but care is needed. If the velocity is too high, the required pressure drop and the subsequent work required by the pump can increase significantly. For vertical flow, a good  starting velocity can be taken as twice the solid’s settling velocity. The main aim is to stop the solids from dropping out. Velocities in the range of 1-3 m/s is  a useful rule of thumb.3

The pressure drop for settling slurries can now be determined at the calculated velocity assuming pseudo-homogeneous behaviour, using the slurry’s density and the carrier fluid’s viscosity in established pressure drop calculation and applying a correction factor. A correction factor of 25% is suggested in Perry’s Chemical Engineers’ Handbook3.

Note that the above is for solids heavier than the carrier fluid. Depending on the solid particle size, at particular concentrations the particles begin to interact with each other and can start to affect the slurry’s viscosity. This is discussed further with calculations provided in the Processing of Solid-Liquid Suspensions, Chapter 112. Appendix 3, Warman Slurry Pumping Handbook4, also has useful calculations and correlations for water-based slurries.

Perry’s Chemical Engineers’ Handbook

Figure 2: Durand factor for minimum suspension velocity (from Govier and Aziz, the flow of complex mixtures in pipes, Van Nostrand Reinhold, New York, 1972)

For non-settling slurries, the resultant slurry typically displays non-Newtonian behaviour, and its rheology and behaviour must be determined empirically to ascertain the work required by the pump. The pressure drop for these can then be calculated using established pressure drop calculations depending on the slurry viscosity and density calculated.

Other things to consider before moving onto pump selection are:

• slip conditions – when the solid and carrier velocities differ significantly;
• pipe size – ensure the pipe ID is considerably bigger than maximum particle size (6-10x is recommended2);
• piping design (using recirculation loops to ensure the slurry is constantly moving; using falls, so the  slurry drains to a safe point; using long radius bends; installing rodding or flushing points; minimising bends; minimising dead legs; minimising suction pipework);
• static head requirements; and
• available NPSH.

The solid particle will play a crucial part in selecting the material of the wetted parts. The following, amongst other things, should be considered:

• are the solids hard or soft? ie are they abrasive?
• will pumping the slurry cause erosion?
• are the solids corrosive? This applies to the carrier fluid.

Pump types

As with many pump duties, both rotary and positive-displacement pumps can be utilised. The following are some of the aspects to consider when selecting the type of pump for your slurry. However, always check with specialist pump suppliers before making a final decision.

Centrifugal pumps

The most common pumps generally in use are centrifugal pumps. When specifying this type of pump, as a minimum, the following must be considered:

• Impeller type – A recessed impeller type can be used, the design minimises contact between the particles and the impeller thereby minimising wear on the impeller whilst being gentle on the particles. Open impeller types can be used, as they are generally easier to clean and maintain. Closed impellers are often regarded as having the best efficiency but can be difficult to clean. The thickness should have suitable wear allowance. You should also consider any impact caused by the required impeller speed.
• Casing type – Metal casings can be used. These may be lined with rubber for added protection or as a sacrificial wear part. Split casings can also be considered, but these can be expensive. The thickness should have suitable wear allowance.
• Clearances – Slurry centrifugal pumps should have larger clearances than pure liquid pumps, to allow solids to pass through but also to reduce the velocity within the pump, thereby minimising wear.

These are just some of the things to consider when selecting a centrifugal pump for a slurry duty. In direct liaison with a pump vendor, the designer must choose the best options for their system. They should also consider any impact on the shaft and seals, and ensure there will be no issues with cavitation.

Centrifugal pumps are differential head devices and therefore, the head generated is based on properties of the fluid.

Warman Slurry Pumping Handbook

Figure 3: Example operating curve and efficiency curve for a mixture of solids and water only

Often, the operating curve and efficiency curve provided by pump vendors are that of water, so a way of translating those figures is often needed. An example is shown in Figure 34. It also includes a ratio for the driver efficiency which would also assist in confirming the pump motor.

Note that the curve is only for slurries whose carrier fluid is water. Moreover, it is for Warman pumps. For similar correlations and fluids other than water, speak to your pump vendor.

Positive displacement pumps

There are various types of positive displacement pumps which may be utilised in pumping slurries: air-operated diaphragm pumps, peristaltic, rotary lobe, progressive cavity pumps, and piston diaphragm pumps to name a few. Assessing all of these to the same degree as the centrifugal pump above will be a significant undertaking and is outside the scope of this article. Instead, I’ve summarised different pump types used in my experience and highlighted specific things to consider in relation to handling slurries.

Positive displacement (PD) pumps are generally useful for fluids, which demonstrate pseudo-plastic behaviour. The pumps are better equipped to overcome that initial resistance to  flow. They generally run at lower speeds compared to centrifugal pumps and are therefore consequently gentler on the solid particles. However, some PD pumps are known to generate acceleration losses, which must be accounted for.

Air-driven diaphragm pumps

Generally, I have found air-driven diaphragm pumps to be suitable for handling slurries. However, as with centrifugal pumps, abrasion and erosion can be an issue, particularly with the balls and seats that form part of the check valve assembly. If the right material is not selected, the balls can be eroded to a point where they no longer seal properly, causing the pump to not operate efficiently. The same thoughts can be applied to piston diaphragm pumps.

Things to consider (specifically related to slurry handling) include material of check valve assembly; material of diaphragm; and clearances (the maximum particle size the pump can handle).

Peristaltic pumps

Peristaltic pumps are alternatives to air-driven diaphragm pumps. Unlike the diaphragm pumps, there are no balls or check valves to maintain. To put it simply, the only things which require maintenance are the motor and the tube. The main advantage of this pump type is the capability to handle slurries up to 80% w/w solids (this is the highest value I’ve seen claimed, and should be confirmed with your pump vendor). A limiting factor in its selection is the maximum discharge pressure, and this is limited ultimately by the tube properties. Things to consider include tube material (hence tube life), and maximum discharge pressure.

Gear, lobe and ECP pumps

In these pump types, fluid is moved in the spaces between the teeth of the gear pump, lobes or pistons. They typically are specified for slurries with soft particles. ECP pumps are known  for dealing well with slurries that contain solids which settle readily, as they can be scooped up once flow is resumed. The clearances are usually quite tight in these pump types and any slurries which contain abrasive solids would cause excessive wear on these pumps5.

Things to consider include slurry type, and solid characteristics.

Cross section of an ECP pump: Learn how it works at https://bit.ly/2FXMGbU

Progressive cavity pumps

Used extensively in the wastewater and process industries, this pump is well known for handling slurries. To improve wear resistance whilst pumping slurries, the rotor may be coated. The more abrasive the solids in the slurry the better it may be to operate the pump more slowly, ie select a larger pump and operate at a slower speed. Additionally however, if the pump is operated slower then solids may fall out of suspension and cause blockages within the pump. Be careful when looking to handle larger diameter solids. A limit of 45 mm is stated in Jones’ Pump Station Design.7

Things to consider include solid characteristics (size and abrasiveness), slurry type (do they settle easily?) and seal arrangement.

Conclusion

Selecting a suitable pump for a slurry application can be a tricky business. There are many variables to consider, some of which have been mentioned in this article. The overriding message  though is to ensure that the solids remain in suspension and to minimise wear and blockages. The above is provided for discussion and general guidance purposes only. For specific cases, you should gather as much information as possible on the carrier fluid and solids, and discuss options with a relevant pump vendor.

References

1. Sinnot, R and Towler, G, Chemical Engineering Design, Fifth Edition, Elsevier, 2009.

2. Processing of Solid-Liquid Suspension, ed Ayazi Shamlou, P,   Chapter 11 by Shook, CA, Chapter 12 Etchells, AW, Butterworth-Heinemann, 1993.

3. Green, DW and Perry, RH, Perry’s Chemical Engineers’ Handbook, Chapter 6, 8th Edition, McGraw-Hill, 2007.

Suggested reading:
Introduction to the advantages and application fields of flue gas ...

For more slurry pump spare partsinformation, please contact us. We will provide professional answers.

4. Warman Slurry Pumping Handbook, Warman International, Feb 2000.

5. https://bit.ly/2Ud76ls

6. Coulson, JM, Richardson, JF, Backhurst, JR, Harker, JH, Coulson and Richardson’s Chemical Engineering Volume 1 - Fluid Flow, Heat Transfer and Mass Transfer, 6th Edition, Elsevier, 1999.

7. Jones, GM, Pumping Station Design, revised 3rd edition), Elsevier, 2008.

As an industry leader in pump manufacturing, the in-house team at GATOR Pump, Inc. produces high-quality trailer pumps, hydraulic pumps, vertical pumps, floating pumps, and more. We specialize in customized, efficient, and affordable pump solutions for effectively transporting water, slurries, sludge, and other various heavy solids in the most difficult and remote operating locations. 

Our high-performance GATOR Trailer PTO Pump is well-known throughout the industry for its rugged design and simple maintenance requirements. Our centrifugal pumps are considered among the most reliable and durable products available on the market today, and we are committed to producing high-quality equipment that is built to last: our team stands behind each of our pumps, and service after the sale is our hallmark.

GATOR Pump offers slurry pumps, also known as sludge pumps, for high solids-handling performance with the rapid deployment and portability you need to get the job done. Learn more about the types of slurry, what to consider when selecting a slurry pump, and the myriad of slurry pump applications across industries.

What Is Slurry?

The slurry is composed of solids suspended within a liquid. This fluid will have viscosities ranging from thin to thick in substance, with varying temperatures and sizes of suspended particles. Unlike pure water, transporting slurries can lead to corrosion and abrasion within pumping equipment.

There is a virtually limitless number of substances that are considered slurries. Some slurries are intentional, like foods, paints, and cement. Other slurries need to be managed accordingly, like pond muck or wastewater. 

Common varieties of slurries include:

• Soil slurry.

  This slurry is a mixture of mud, clay, dirt, sand, silt, rock, and other soil particles in water, which effectively moves the soil media.

• Coal slurry.

  Coal slurry is a byproduct of burning coal for energy production. It is a toxic mix, typically composed of water and coal fly ash.

• Slurry oil.

  This refinery fluid byproduct is generated through fluid catalytic cracking (FCC) units, which contribute to a small portion of the international supply of fuel oil.

• Pulp slurry.

  Pulp slurry has applications in paper production. It is derived from a mixture of solvents and various wood pulps.

• Manure slurry.

  Made up of organic matter and animal waste, manure slurry is useful as fertilizer in agricultural settings. This is achieved by aging and concentrating the manure and organic material in a slurry pit.

• Wastewater.

  Water that humans have already used and contaminated is considered a slurry. This typically pertains to sewage wastewater.

• Sewage sludge.

  This is a semi-solid slurry that is a byproduct of the treatment of sewage wastewater.

• Food processing slurry.

  There are numerous liquified processed foods with a solid base that are considered slurries, such as peanut butter, soups, gelatins, condiments, liquid chocolates, and more.

Considerations When Choosing a Slurry Pump

(Click to Enlarge)

As there are many varieties of slurries, there are many sludge pump types available. Choosing the wrong pump for your application can lead to a decrease in suction effectiveness at best, as well as equipment damage, system downtime, and costly repairs or replacement parts. To make the right slurry pump selection for your specific application, consider five key variables:

Design

Many slurries are corrosive and abrasive. In these cases, it is important to select a pump that has a durable impeller or, alternatively, a rotor. Slurries also tend to have particles of varying sizes and densities. For slurries in which larger solids might be present, you want to select a pump design that won’t clog easily.

The GATOR Sludge Pump is designed with a modification for an in-line slurry valve that facilitates media pumping and handling by utilizing discharge flow to agitate and thin the fluid. After slurry processing, the valve closes, and the sludge removal pump transports the material to the designated discharge point.

Materials

A slurry pump’s material construction will directly impact its effectiveness and longevity. For abrasive slurries that have a neutral pH level, Hi-Chrome is the preferred material for its high Brinell hardness. 

For slurries that are abrasive but have an acidic pH, duplex stainless steel is recommended. This material also maintains a high Brinell level for optimally handling corrosive materials.

Deployment Technique

A slurry pump’s method of deployment is an important consideration when developing its setup. GATOR Pump is a submersible pump and, as the name implies, submersible pumps completely submerge in a liquid. As the pump is submerged, it does not require priming and there are no suction lines or check valves.

Power & Size

A slurry pump’s application will decide its appropriate power needs and the resulting size. To offer optimal longevity while still effectively pumping abrasive liquids, the ideal operational speed for slurry pumps is typically between 900 and 1,200 RPM. Working at slower speeds avoids the wear similar to sandblasting that occurs when the RPM rate exceeds that range.

What Industries Use Slurry Pumps?

 

Slurry pumps have applications in an array of diverse industries.

Irrigation & Agriculture

Our portable sludge pumps are ideal and convenient in agriculture for pumping large amounts of water out of a ditch, canal, stream, or pond. Our pumps don’t require priming, suction lines, or check valves, just submersion in water. Beyond crop irrigation and water transfer, example applications include:

• Weed and water-grass management

• Animal waste removal

• Sediment removal during pond cleaning

Mining & Construction

Mining and construction sites often require continuous flow, and pumps for these industries need the capability to withstand abrasive and corrosive media while effectively maintaining operations. Our pumps are specifically designed to handle these tough slurries in applications like:

• Storm deluge and emergency flood pumping

• Gravel and sand quarry dewatering

• Settling pond containment and water transfer

Wetland & Waterfowl Management

Proper land conservation efforts rely on dependable slurry pumps to transfer water and adequately protect wildlife habitats and wetlands. Our pumps can reach such remote areas, and we’ve worked with both government agencies and conservation organizations to help manage environmental conditions through:

• Flooding wildlife habitats for fishing and hunting purposes

• Mitigating storm surge

• Dewatering for seasonal habitat preparation

Flood Control Drainage

For residential, business, industrial, or agricultural flooding, deploying dependable flood pumps in a timely manner is crucial. Flood water tends to carry suspended solids, and so slurry pumps will provide the best results. Our flood control and drainage pumps are applicable for:

• Wildlife and fish refuge management

• Sewage bypass and stormwater removal

• Emergency response pumping in remote areas

Sludge, Slurry, & Manure Waste Handling

When it comes to pumping manure or other potentially dangerous slurries, certain regulations must be followed. Our pumps are designed to meet the standards set for numerous environments. Our sludge water, slurry, and manure pumps are capable of:

• Transfer pumping for sewage plants

• Manure lagoon management

• Handling landfill leachate

Oil Fields, Refining, & Energy

Slurries are abundant in the petroleum industry, some of which are quite abrasive and thick. Many energy applications demand consistent and continuous flow, and our pumps are capable of this in applications such as:

• Drill mud handling

• Oilfield water and mud injection

• Refinery fire suppression

Partner With GATOR Pump For Your Slurry Pump Needs

Looking for a high-performance slurry pump? GATOR Pump offers efficient, high-quality pumps you can depend on, with capabilities for customizing our products and manufacturing in-house to meet your unique needs. A veteran-owned business since 1977, our company focuses on providing reliable, long-lasting, and cost-effective solutions for a system you can trust. 

For questions about our slurry pumps, contact us by using our online form, giving our team a call at 1-800-735-9811, or sending us an email. For custom solutions, request a quote to begin your project.

For more information, please visit Wear-Resistant Castings for Slurry Pump.